Foreign Information Manipulation and Interference (FIMI) in the Western Hemisphere

By Benoni Belli*


At Brazil’s initiative, the OAS Permanent Council discussed, on November 4, the issue of Foreign Information Manipulation and Interference (FIMI). FIMI poses a challenge to the free formation of political will, the integrity of public debate, and the functioning of institutions. Broadly speaking, FIMI encompasses manipulative, intentional, and coordinated conduct carried out by foreign state or non-state actors, either directly or through proxies. Its techniques include concealing the origin and financing of campaigns, the use of networks of inauthentic accounts, the impersonation of media outlets, and the artificial amplification of content, including through the use of artificial intelligence.

The classical model of Athenian democracy, which presupposed the formation of collective will through free and plural debate among citizens, now appears as a distant ideal, not least because that model of direct democracy would be difficult to implement in mass societies. In representative democracies, the traditional debate on representation has revolved largely around legitimacy, particularly with regard to the functioning of party and electoral systems, the influence of money in campaigns, and the institutional mediation between representatives and those they represent. Asymmetries in the production, dissemination, and consumption of political ideas and public policy proposals have always existed, yet the idealized notion of an individual capable of making informed decisions free from undue constraints remained intact, even if the expression of popular will has been largely confined to elections.

At a time when information channels are increasingly digital, new opportunities for representation emerge, but so do unprecedented challenges. Any individual or group is now capable of disseminating opinions and information far more easily and with the potential to reach millions of people instantly. This apparent symmetry, however, contrasts with the actual asymmetry of the medium through which information flows. Far from being a public square equally accessible to all, public debate and information circulate through a medium that is not neutral, operating on the basis of a business model that disproportionately amplifies content capable of generating engagement, typically content with greater potential for conflict or more extreme viewpoints, with profit serving as the primary driving force. 

In addition to algorithmic discrimination and the inherent preference for content that generates higher levels of engagement, there are paid promotion mechanisms and the corporate preferences of the companies that control these platforms. These factors help explain the unequal and asymmetric dissemination of content, with repercussions for elections and evident impacts, among other areas, on household economies, public health, and the rights of women and children. It is within this environment that we observe the growing trend of foreign information manipulation and interference, adding a disruptive element that goes far beyond the traditional debate on legitimacy and representativeness. It is important to distinguish manipulative operations, which have harmful effects and create inequalities in the dissemination and reception of ideas and narratives, from the legitimate circulation of information and ideas across borders, diplomatic activity, journalism, and international cooperation. 

The foreign origin of information, the external funding of an organization, or the expression of critical viewpoints do not, in themselves, constitute evidence of improper interference. In Europe, where the debate is more advanced, experience has pointed toward strengthening prevention and democratic resilience through media and information literacy, support for independent journalism, greater transparency by digital platforms, and international cooperation. The focus has been on preventing and remedying improper or even unlawful interference without restricting freedom of expression or stigmatizing civil society. Any effort to identify appropriate responses to this new challenge must necessarily involve dialogue with society, academia, legislatures, and government institutions in order to examine regulatory and cooperative alternatives that include clear safeguards for human rights and the protection of freedom of expression, opinion, and criticism.

Within the Inter-American system, the issue is directly related to the defense of representative democracy, the sovereign equality of states, and the principle of non-intervention enshrined in the OAS Charter, as well as to freedom of expression, pluralism, and political participation. The discussion promoted by Brazil within the Organization seeks to examine how these principles apply to contemporary information manipulation operations and what cooperative measures could strengthen national capacities to prevent them. We seek to identify conceptual convergences, assess the adequacy of existing norms, exchange best practices, and recognize possible gaps. We may not be able to eliminate entirely malicious foreign interference or manipulative operations pursued for improper purposes. Nevertheless, a response aimed at minimizing their negative impact is urgently needed if we are to prevent the fundamental premise of representative democracy, namely, the right of citizens to participate freely in shaping their own destiny, from being irreparably eroded.


*Benoni Belli is Ambassador, Permanent Representative of Brazil to the Organization of American States (OAS).

 
 
Next
Next

Lula Wins and Trump Loses: A New Perspective for the World